Benro Tripods... Any Good?

Hello,


I had some time today and stopped by my local Camera shop in MA. My main objective was to handle the Aluminum and Carbon Fiber versions of the Manfrotto 055PROXB Tripod or the 055CXPRO3 model. I like those models because of the quality, height and the price. Gitzo isn't in the budget. I say height because I am 6' 5".


The salesman asked me to check out the Benro A-297EX (Aluminum) at $130 (i think) and the Benro C-297EX (Carbon Fiber) at $250. He insisted the quality was equal to the Manfrotto tripods. The Benro models come with a carrying case too. They appear to be discontinued models that they have limited quantities of. The Benros were lighter than the Manfrotto models, had similar features and seemed decent. There are very few reviews out there, not a good sign, so I figured I would ask you guys.


Are they any good?





This store tried to sell me Promaster filters before swearing they were as good as B + W. Turns out they are glorified Hoya filters.





Thanks,


Brett

Only a fanatic (or someone with extremely demanding tasks) would go for a Gitzo versus high-end equivalent from Manfroto, Giottos or Benro, especially if that person is on a tight budget. Same can be said about B+W versus high-end Hoya filters. I am using the Hoya HD circular polarizer with my 16-35 'L' lens and I can assure you that it is AT LEAST as good as any of B+W or Heliopan circular polarizers I own, plus it transmits more light overall than any other circular polarizer.


So, when you choose a tripod, the brand should be your last concern. Choose the one that you feel will serve you best. A tripod is very important for some types of photography, but unlike cameras and lenses, you are totally capable of testing it on your own, without relying on technical reviews. Handling tripods at a store should be enough to help you make up your mind.

i like mine, fits nicely on my Think Tank backpack. As a pure hobbyist, I couldn

Hey Brett,


Which camera shop, if you don

I just purchased the 055xprob and I am incredibly impressed with it and it's features. I don't think I agree with Firestarter, but to each his own. For me, brand always has something to do with my purchase, in virtually everything I buy. That's not to say I buy the most expensive brand, but a brand is typically more than just an expensive name. It is frequently a reputation (quality, customer service, etc) and the small additional features that add up.


"Testing" a tripod in a camera shop should not be considered adequate either if you don't want to trust the judgment and reviews of other photographers. That is unless you will be using the tripod exclusively in a studio setting where you will always have ideal conditions.


On to the meat of your post....Being a recent purchaser of the 055xprob, I highly recommend it. Though, as you probably now know, it is not very light. I don't really know anything about the Benro tripods, so I certainly won't knock them, but I just bought my tripod for $160 with free shipping from B&H. That's only a $30 difference from the Benro, though you won't get a carry case.


Out of curiosity, what head do you plan on using?


Braden

How about Benro ball heads? They have them at Keh for a decent price. I already have a tripod (a very heavy contractor tripod that is as sturdy as heck!) so no problems there.


John.

Thanks for your responses,


It sounds like erno has put some mileage on his Benro. I did like the Benro.


This particular model wasn't as fine tuned as the Manfrotto but it was also $150 less. The thought of a Carbon Fiber tripod for $250 really caught my eye, if it's almost as good. The sales rep. said it normally retails for $400. I'm just a little concerned with the brand. I've heard of Benro, just never considered them. I am like Braden, looking for a good brand with a good reputation. Even the aluminum model was lighter than the Manfrotto 055proxb and reading reviews shows me how much weight can make or break a long day of carrying it. Braden also brings up a good point "Testing" a tripod in a camera shop should not be considered adequate either if you don't want to trust the judgment and reviews of other photographers. That is unless you will be using the tripod exclusively in a studio setting where you will always have ideal conditions." about field trials over toying with it in a store setting. I will go by and try it out with my body/lens combo before doing anything.


The head I am looking at is the Giottos MH-1301 from B & H.





Brett





P.S. HAPPY THANKSGIVING[:)]

I

I like to buy things that can handle more than I need them too. That way they never fall short. Thanks for the reply.

Hi Braden,


How is the tripod? Do you mind the weight? Or even a better question, does the build quality make the extra weight worth it? Trying to decide before those Benros are gone. Adorama is selling the Carbon Fiber one for $350 and My camera shop had it for $250.


Thanks for your input,


Brett

Hi Braden,


How is the tripod? Do you mind the weight? Or even a better question, does the build quality make the extra weight worth it? Trying to decide before those Benros are gone. Adorama is selling the Carbon Fiber one for $350 and My camera shop had it for $250.


Thanks for your input,


Brett

I have 2 heavy duty CF Benro

I have a couple of Benro ball heads, I tried them out for a few minutes and put them back in their box. I was very disappointed in their quality. My Benro tripods are just fine though.

Which Benro tripods do you have?