Quote Originally Posted by neuroanatomist
Wow - what search engine are you using? Bing-o? [img]/emoticons/emotion-4.gif[/img]

Yahoo.


Quote Originally Posted by neuroanatomist
Yes, it is. Resistant ≠ impervious. It's a zoom lens.

true.


Quote Originally Posted by neuroanatomist
Regardless, I think you may be unfairly judging an excellent lens, which Bryan calls, "...one of the best general purpose lenses available."

quite possible.


Quote Originally Posted by neuroanatomist
Thanks also, Brendan, for your suggestion of 24-105mm + a UWA - that combo vs. the 17-55mm will be a tough decision for an upcoming trip.

I'd say the advantage of the 17-55 is indoors, and the 24-105mm is outdoors. It depends on where you shoot IMO.


brendan