Question, why are you using it more of a video then a camera?

Just my opinion, if you're going to shoot video a lot, buy a HD Camcorder, it'd be cheaper IMO

But if you're asking which lens to get for both? It really comes down to $$ IMO and fStop, 2.8 vs 4. I'm a big fan of the 2.8 and lower lens, but that's just me, but it also cost double the $$ half the time


I think both are great lens for the range.