New to the world of ND and CP filters

[Kayaker72]

+1.

I don't have much to add. In addition to Lee, B+W, I would consider Singh-Ray. Also, the website, at least that I've come across, that probably provides the most filter options is 2filters.

My set up is similar to Neuro's in that I currently use screw in solid ND filters and 4x6" graduated ND filters. I have B+W 6 stop (most used) and 10 stop screw in ND filters (77 mm thread). But I use the cokin filter holder for my graduated ND filters. I have graduated ND filters from Cokin, Lee, and Singh-Ray. I think Cokin is underrated, but, with that said, I have moved to a combination of Lee and Singh Ray grad NDs when I pack. I don't have the Lee big stopper, but I am thinking about it. I just added the 24-70 II and need to solve my 82 mm thread dilemma.

Unfortunately for my wallet, I can imagine situations where it will be best to have both systems. The screw in ND filters are far more secure (IMO), and convenient if you are going to shoot, then move, and then shoot again. Live View will AF through even a 10 stop ND filter (which negates some of the benefit of being able to drop in the Lee big stopper after composition). Phase AF and Live View will AF through my 6 stop ND filter. The issue I run into with solid screw in ND filters is when I want to combine the grad and solid ND. For example, I was just shooting lighthouses at sunset. I wanted the to blur the ocean (10 stop ND screw in) and use the grad ND for the sky to get it closer to the lighthouse. I was shooting wide (~24 mm) so I get vignetting if I combine the screw in ND filter and the filter holder. So I ended up hand holding the grad ND over my screw in ND filter. Ultimately, I must have flinched as light got in the side and ruined the shot. In this instance, the Lee Big Stopper would have been the solution. But most other circumstances, I prefer the screw in filters, and have used the hand holding technique successfully before.

BTW, I tend to like Darwin Wigget's reviews. One of his reviews is why I went with the cokin filter holder over the Lee. I can't find that link, but I saw he has an ebook on filters for $10. When I have time, I may get it myself. But I have enough else going on right now.