Not Quite Sure What I Think of This... Need Some Critiques.

[alexniedra]

This seemed like "just another photo" from a recent trip in Montreal, until I converted it to black and white and cropped it slightly from the bottom. I sort of think it emphasizes the size of these trees relative to the people walking through them. I think it's a bit dramatic, and I like the way the trees form a frame for the people walking.



Let me know what you think, and reassure me if you think this deserves a spot in the "selects' folder. []


- Aleks





EOS 40D, EF 24-70 L


ISO 500, f/11, 1/250 sec. @ 24mm


[img]/cfs-file.ashx/__key/CommunityServer.Components.UserFiles/00.00.00.26.94/_5F00_MG_5F00_4961.jpg[/img]

[Sean Setters]

All I see in the image space is "Content Protected by Owner." :-(

[alexniedra]

Weird... Sorry about that Sean. Anybody else experiencing this problem?



I'll repost an image directly from my computer. []

[steve_m]

Yep, I see the same. No picture either.

[Jon Ruyle]

It's a fairly nice "Content protected by owner", in case you were wondering about that. I would have framed it slightly differently and stopped down a bit, but other than that...

[Dan Fleming]

the text seems a little out of focus, but maybe that is just the low contrast. The lock could use some higher contrast too.

[neuroanatomist]

the text seems a little out of focus, but maybe that is just the low contrast

No, it's clearly over-cropped andthe lock and text are zoomed just beyond the point of pixelation. Why anyone with a 10 megapixel camera would feel the need to apply a digital zoom is beyond me. Simply beyond me. [:P]

[TucsonTRD]

I seem to be seeing some slight vignetting...could be my monitor I guess.

[alexniedra]

LOL Real funny!


I uploaded my own version. Any better?

[Todd Ovick]

i guess i would like to see some more foreground in front of the people, otherwise great shot...i might be looking at the wrong photo though....considering the recent replies to your thread.....