Quote Originally Posted by bburns223


Well, I'd say buying both lenses is a waste, but that's just my opinion.


I would avoid lenses that have been dropped. If you're spending $1k on a lens make sure you don't get a dud. Play it safe.



I think keeping both lenses may be a waste, yes. I've seen the 300mm f/4L IS come up on Craigslist at $900-1000 and disappear within a day or two. So, I think I'd have no trouble selling it down the road with no loss, same with the 200mm f/2.8L that I also picked up for ~40% less than a new copy.


I'm definitely leaning against the dropped and refurbed lens, though. If I do decide I prefer the prime, that would be harder to sell, too, since I'l be up front about the issue.


Thanks for all your input, Brendan!