Results 1 to 10 of 62

Thread: My First Tripod. Recommendations please.

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Senior Member ham's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Posts
    384
    As always, great info.

    I couldn't give you a price really because until your post I hadn't any idea what the going rates were. Carbon fibre really won't be necessary I don't think, weight saving isn't an issue so much as ensuring I get something decent which won't be extortionate.

    You say best of the best runs at upwards of a grand and that something costing £100 will be rubbish, but how about the middle ground? How much would I have to spend to get some thing that I won't regret buying? Are we talking 200-300? Or more like 400-500?

    What are the factors that make the extra money worth spending? Purely stability and usability? Or things like weight and strength?

    Sorry for all the questions, massively lacking in tripod knowledge.

  2. #2
    Senior Member neuroanatomist's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    Boston, MA
    Posts
    3,908
    Quote Originally Posted by ham View Post
    How much would I have to spend to get some thing that I won't regret buying? Are we talking 200-300? Or more like 400-500?

    What are the factors that make the extra money worth spending? Purely stability and usability? Or things like weight and strength?
    I'd say £200 at a minimum, £400-500 would be better.

    For the legs, the extra money gets you added stability with less weight (carbon fiber is lighter than aluminum but transmits vibrations less). An added plus is that CF doesn't transfer heat well, meaning it doesn't freeze your hands like aluminum (which transfers heat very well, and that's why my Calphalon cookware is aluminum). CF legs are much easier to carry, meaning it's more likely you'll bring the tripod with you.

    For the head, the extra money gets you stability. A less expensive head will droop, either when you let go of the camera or over time, or both. With better heads, when you lock them down, they stay put. A head clamp that's compatible with the Arca-Swiss system is a good long-term investment - that's an industry standard (although neither Gitzo nor Manfrotto adhere to it), so camera plates, L-brackets if you get them, lens plates if you get them, will all be compatible with many other types of heads.

    Looking at Jessops for some costs, here's what I'd recommend as a starter set:

    • Manfrotto 055XPROB = £105
    • Manfrotto 498RC2 = £87
    • TOTAL = £192

    You might want to read this article, which advises just getting the best from the start, and makes some good points. But take a rational approach (and keep in mind that the author just assumes you'll chuck the gear you don't want anymore into the bin, instead of selling it to recoup some of the loss).

    As a mid-level solution, I'd consider:

    • Manfrotto 190CXPRO4 = £200 (if you're over 175cm tall, the 055CXPRO4 = £300 would be better)
    • Manfrotto 498 = £80 (note - just the 498, without RC# clamp/plate)
    • Wimberley C-12 clamp = £65 (note - the Wimberley distributor in the UK is bobrigby.com)
    • Wimberley P-5 plate = £44
    • TOTAL = £389-489

    One more suggestion - go into a shop and try some out. Manfrotto uses lever-locks for the legs, other brands use twist-locks. Play with the heads. See how easy it is to extend/collapse the legs. Find something that's comfortable for you to use.

    Hope that helps...

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •