Thanks
When I started shooting, because of the ripple on the water I decided to do long exposures. I thought it was a better look than the rippled look.
Part of the reason they look saturated is that I purposly saturated it in post and turned contrast very low so that it gave it the appearance of a chalky reflection in the water.
The biggest reason they look so different is that the water is acting as a filter and diffusing the light, where the real lights are direct and constant. It is most likely picking up color out of the darker water as well. Maybe in this situation if I had used a ND graduated filter and brought the real lights down a stop or two it would have evened it out?